WMsearch
/blag/

Examples of truly great nonfiction in languages other than English?

wed18feb2009—08w049d13%—19h36m00s—0utc
books, announces, english, questions, recommendations, readings, lists, ★ favorites, videos, original content, science, languages, spanish

I hunger for nonfiction because I love learning and because I long to expand my life, my experiences, my thought — all of them so sadly limited. One particular obsession of mine lately is to find truly great nonfiction in languages other than English. It’s not that there’s a lack of it in English (quite the opposite) but rather a nagging suspicion of Western (American-European) parochialism, of missing out on great works and different perspectives I can’t even imagine.

The surprising thing, though, is how hard it is to found it. I have no trouble finding truly great, truly unique fiction in many languages but my trawlings for worthwhile nonfiction turn out almost always empty.

Perhaps it’s a matter of nonfiction not being as readily exportable and thus translated to other languages. Perhaps there’s just not a English market for translated nonfiction. Perhaps English just sucks into it most modern nonfiction writers, whatever their native language. Perhaps whoever wants to be widely read these days chooses to write only in English. Perhaps nonfiction in other languages is “remade” rather than “subtitled” into English. Perhaps I need to be introduced to it by a native speaker. Perhaps nonfiction as we now conceive it is a very modern meta-genre. Perhaps nonfiction is a Western thing. Perhaps nonfiction needs a massive community of hundreds of millions of wealthy, educated speakers to foster the few who will read it, let alone write it. Perhaps I’m so drenched in the Anglosphere that I only get it‘s version of who’s relevant. Perhaps just as Greek, Latin, Chinese, Arab, or French had their golden nonfiction age, this is English’s. Perhaps.

Lacking an answer, my guess these days is that English nonfiction is, personally, by far the only worthwhile modern nonfiction in the world.

But I’m still looking. And so, dear Interwebs, please help me out, what examples do you know of truly great nonfiction in languages other than English?

Anything goes, as long as it’s general, nonlocal, non-culturally-specific (say, no books on Kohdo, the Japanese art of smelling incense, or on the cuisine in the Mexican state of Oaxaca) but to give you a more specific idea of what I’m looking for, here are some subjects dear to my heart and some outstanding representatives within them (with the few items in languages other than English bolded):

Extra points (not-at-all-necessary but cool parameters):

𝕏 Follow me  |  ⌂ Back to ELZR.com

11 Comments

Sergio G.

Ok, va el primero. El libro de las cochinadas de Julieta Fierro y Juan Tonda. Lo encuentras en la sección de niños de Gandhi. Si has leído mucho, posiblemente no descubras nada nuevo. Pero el tema escatológico con los dibujos de Juan Tonda… lo colocó en la cabeza del libro de ciencias Mexicano mas divertido que haya leído.

Eldila

I would suggest reading The Black Swan by Nassim Nicholas Taleb if you haven’t read it yet. It is one of the better books that I have read recently.

elzr

Sergio!: Hey, hello man! I actually thought of you as I was writing this article, I was sure you would have something to suggest :) Thanks for the (first) tip, the book sounds fun! I’ll check it out next time I’m in Mexico (end of this year, most likely).

Eldila: Yeah, I’m sure it must be really good, I went to a talk by Taleb back in SF and was very impressed by the man. It is exactly the kind of nonfiction I dig and yet, though, the author himself is Lebanese, he has lived most of his life in Western countries and the book was originally published in English.
Eldila

@elzr: Even though Taleb spent majority of his life in western society, his experience and ideas are far from typical western culture. I guess my book suggestion only gets two points (if I stretch the definition a bit). One for the book being less than 50 years old. Another for being third culture-ish. Either way, it is a good book to read. However, it might not contain the “culture” that you are currently looking for in a book. Anyways, I have been reading your blog for awhile, so I thought I should finally comment on something :D. Thanks for the post and I will definitely be looking into some of the books that you posted (at least the english ones).

elzr

@Eldila: Yup, totally, Nicholas Taleb belongs on this list. Thanks for reading and for “coming out” (“commenting out”? :). Welcome!

elzr

2 interesting lists of nonfiction recently stumbled on: The Modern Library’s Top 100 nonfiction books of the century, which is a good list though even more English parochial than mine, and the similar but more cosmopolitan National Review list of the 100 best non-fiction books of the century, which includes a nice blurb about most books.

Another interesting thing is that I don’t think there’s a readily available, commonly used word to even name the concept of nonfiction in Spanish, French or Italian—a big hint that the metagenre hasn’t coalesced there.
jaimonkey

Im not sure if this counts but: I read this guy’s work in humanities class

http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/al-ghazali/

more to come later
Jordan

Do the classics qualify?  e.g. Herodotus’ Histories, Ovid’s Metamorphosis, Plato’s Dialogs, etc.

Jordan

What about transcendent anthropological studies, with aspirations of exploring universal truths – Levi-Strauss’ Tristes Tropiques comes to mind.

Jordan

this i only know in translation, but it is a cornerstone of my foundational theoretical library: von Thünen’s The Isolated State (Der isolierte Staat (1826)) – the first explicitly spatial treatment of economic space.  Surely this counts?  The concepts are elegant, powerful, and overall waaaaay ahead of its time.  On the beauty of expression, however, I really couldn’t say since I can’t read the German original.

elzr

Thanks for the responses guys! You made me want to show some further love to the post and so I’ve improved its format, pruned it here and there, and rethought about the question for a while. I came up with Marjane Satrapi’s Persepolis), her French-language comic, and Lift 09, a cool TED-like Swiss conference that’s making its mostly-French-language talks available.

Speaking of French and essays, the word itself comes from French and French language is famous for essayists, anyone know any modern French-language masters of the genre?

I also remembered Umberto Eco is well regarded for his Italian essays and nonfiction books on semiotics. Korea Unmasked is also an interesting comic essay on Korea in Asia written originally in Korean. My chemist cousin once warmly recommended me Alexander Oparin’s The Origin of life, written originally in Russian. Andy Clark, whom I deeply admire, references the Russian psychologist Lev Vygotsky frequently so I’m intrigued.

It occurs to me that an interesting way to look for this kind of books would be to trawl through the list of nonfiction books annually translated into English—wonder how can I actually do that?

@jaimonkey: Thanks for the mention, Al Ghazali seems like an amazing person. Reading about him I got to Avicenna, who I had of course heard about before but never realized how much of a sheer genius he was.

@Jordan: Yes, classics count, though the focus is on modernity. I actually thought about Tristes Tropiques but didn’t include it because I haven’t read it—of course it counts! Thanks for the mention to that economics book, I couldn’t find an English version online to skim, but I found a German one.